St. Elmo Steak House

The oldest steakhouse in Indianapolis (that is still in its original location) is an elegant affair. Uber expensive, expect to pay at least a couple hundred bucks for two. It's a very recognizable landmark as it's been in the same building since 1902 when it first opened its doors. The restaurant was founded by Joseph Stahl who named it after the patron saint of sailors. Walk-ins are accepted but reservations are recommended!